PFI Reset: NISTA has set the framework

NISTA’s PFI Reset guidance, published on 16th November 2026, marks a practical shift in how the government approaches mid-life and expiring PFI contracts. 

Since 2021 Curshaw has asserted that resetting underperforming or strained projects needs a jointly owned, evidence-based review agreed by both parties, rather than an exercise focused on exploiting deductions. Through continued engagement that approach is now reflected in NISTAs published Reset Routemap which closely mirrors our proposed methodology developed for complex project resets, Counterpoint. 

NISTA developed the guidance utilising input from the public and private sectors. As a founding adviser of the Association of Infrastructure Investors in PPPs (AIIP), Curshaw contributed to that dialogue, and we welcome how much of the market’s feedback the final suite reflects, from both sides of the contract.

Our findings here, build out on our earlier article, “We were correct and the industry is now headed in the right direction”. It sets out where NISTA’s guidance aligns with the positions we have published since 2021, how Counterpoint delivers the framework in practice, and where the remaining operational questions sit for live projects.

From published positions to government guidance

Many organisations across the public and private sectors have advocated a more collaborative approach to PFI management. Comparing the positions Curshaw has set out since 2021 against NISTA’s November 2026 suite shows substantial alignment on the core principles of reset:

Curshaw’s published positionNISTA’s published guidance
Start with a jointly agreed baseline review, rather than a forensic search for deductionsEach party completes a Project Stocktake, with a joint exercise recommended, and the Reset Routemap begins by sharing results
Agree a single version of the truth before taking corrective actionThe stocktake is structured to surface where views differ, so both parties understand the other’s position before deciding next steps
Proportionality: not every project requires a full resetReset is reserved for issues too material to be resolved through day-to-day contract management
Reset is a joint endeavour, not a unilateral process imposed on one partyReset delivers better outcomes when it is jointly led rather than driven by one party alone
Under-management and information asymmetry exist on both sides of the contractThe authority’s own resourcing and contract management are in scope, with under-management recognised as an issue
Adviser incentives do not always align with long-term project stabilityAdvisers must not assume the role of Senior Responsible Owners (SROs) or SPV directors, nor unilaterally determine the course of a reset
A reset must hold through to expiryDelivery includes a dedicated stage to embed best practice and transition back to business as usual

NISTA describes reset as an opportunity rather than a sign of failure, and advises authorities to exhaust a joint approach before considering unilateral action. It is also clear that not every project needs a reset. Proportionality is built into the guidance from the outset.

Counterpoint: mapped to the Reset Routemap

NISTA has defined the framework. Counterpoint is an established delivery method structured around four core principles: joint endeavour, proportionality, fixed-fee certainty and long-term sustainability.

Counterpoint stageWhat Curshaw deliversNISTA Routemap equivalent
1. Joint appointmentEngaged jointly by both parties, or by one party with a collateral warranty to the other, so our responsibility is to the project itselfJoint stocktake and a jointly led reset process
2. Survey and reviewIndependent condition surveys sized to need based on an objective assessment of data, alongside a review of the service specification and payment mechanism against a consistent standardProject Stocktake, Building Blocks and the Asset Condition Playbook
3. Remedy, rectify and improveA shared definition of what good looks like, transparent rectification plans and agreed governanceReset set-up, planning and implementation
4. Embed and sustainSoftware-enabled performance reporting and periodic independent assurance through to contract expiryEmbedding best practice and moving on

The joint appointment model addresses a common structural flaw in PFI advisory work: an adviser paid solely by one party naturally optimises for that client’s commercial position. An adviser accountable to the project can give objective technical and commercial findings to both sides. We have applied this joint model in the health sector, advising an NHS Trust and its SPV together on adapting facilities management delivery. 

Where the guidance should go further

The core framework now reflects a position both sides of the market can support, but several operational areas remain partly resolved or open to interpretation. It's fair to say that some of these gaps are in the nature of arms length advice rather than Government mandate. However we would urge further clarity of that guidance framework for the reasons suggested here and to ensure greater consistency of approach:

Open pointCurrent status in guidancePractical implication for live projects
Relief during resetThe Asset Condition Playbook permits agreed relief during rectification, whereas the reset guidance says relief should not be assumedParties must still negotiate the scope, triggers and duration of any payment mechanism relief project by project
Payment mechanism adjustmentsDedicated guidance is still in developmentProjects changing operational practices need a defined bedding-in period, so new working methods do not immediately trigger fresh deductions
Financial model accessNISTA explains why authorities need visibility of the financial model, without resolving how to manage its commercial sensitivityParties need clear protocols on what financial data is strictly necessary to share and how confidentiality is protected
SPV discretion and supply chainsOnly partly addressed in the published suiteReset agreements must account for where decision-making authority sits across SPVs, funders, investors and FM subcontractors
Programmatic coordinationNo cross-departmental programme to sequence resets or manage survey capacity is set outWithout central coordination, simultaneous resets risk bottlenecks in technical surveying and specialist advisory capacity
Joint procurement rulesThe Playbook outlines a joint tender process but does not explain how it fits with public procurement rulesOne route: Counterpoint can be engaged by a single party with a collateral warranty for the benefit of the other, so the adviser’s responsibility is still to the project itself


Why advisers must see both sides

Public-private partnerships are long-term operational contracts, not zero-sum transactions. Contracting authorities need reliable asset performance, statutory compliance and a clean handback at expiry. SPVs, investors and service providers need deliverable specifications, consistent contract interpretation and predictable cash flows. In practice, these objectives depend on the same outcome: a stable, functioning asset.

When advisers have only ever represented one side of the market, they tend to treat a reset as a zero-sum negotiation. Curshaw’s clients include funds, project owners and directors, and contracting authorities, and our team brings experience across more than 95 PFI projects, covering expiry preparation, handback delivery and post-PFI transition. Our breadth of experience  helps both parties reach workable agreements faster.

How we deliver reset work

NISTA notes that parties may need specialist support and advice, without prescribing how that support should be structured. Curshaw works to two clear commercial rules.

Fixed-fee delivery. Open-ended time-and-materials billing puts the focus on finding more problems rather than fixing them. We work on a fixed-fee basis, so costs are predictable and controllable. Authorities gain budget certainty, SPVs have a clear end point, and the team stays focused on resolution.

Commercially led, with legal advice tightly scoped. Most issues identified by NISTA, such as weak governance, unreliable performance data and misaligned working practices, are operational and commercial, not legal. When a reset becomes legally led either by legal advisors or because of their advice, positions harden and routine correspondence is drafted with an eye on future adjudication. Our RPD approach (Review and Reset, Prepare, Deliver) starts from an objective, standards-based assessment of project performance with an evidential basis. Where formal contractual interpretation is needed, it should be referred to the parties’ legal advisers on a tightly defined brief, while the reset itself remains commercially led.

Starting with the Project Stocktake

With the policy framework established, the priority is execution across mid-life and expiring contracts. NISTA’s recommended starting point is the Project Stocktake. Where it shows more work is needed, Curshaw has three established ways in:

  1. Reset assessment and support. An independent assessment of how the project operates and how the interfaces between the parties are managed (governance, reporting and contract administration), with a service improvement plan.

  2. Project operational review. A RAG rating against Curshaw’s best practice standard, with a single-page dashboard for senior stakeholders and a prescriptive action plan. It is designed to sit at the interface between the contracting parties.

  3. Counterpoint. A full joint reset, from joint appointment through to sustaining the fix to expiry.

To discuss how NISTA’s reset framework applies to a specific contract, or how Counterpoint works in practice, get in touch with our team.

Next
Next

Sustainable Investment in Infrastructure within the Fiscal Rules